Special Report: The Used Car Bubble Is Bursting

Used Cars - special report
Photo Credit: alexmillos/Shutterstock.com
Iíve talked on the Car Pro Show for eight weeks about used car prices being sky high. I monitor the Manheim Dallas auction weekly so I can report to my listeners up-to-date information about trade values. I have also warned everyone that this bubble would burst and prices would drop hard and fast.

Just last Saturday I talked about every vehicle, especially trucks and SUVs, bringing way over MMR (Manheim Market Report). MMR is the gauge car dealers use to know the current market values, unlike the old days when dealers used the Black Book or NADA book.

A week ago Wednesday, pickups and popular SUVs were bringing $2000 to $5000 over the MMR guide, some even much more.

This week, things changed dramatically. Sure, some vehicles brought MMR and a few brought slightly more, but the majority of vehicles sold struggled to get to MMR and a huge number of them didnít even get close to MMR.

Here were some vehicles that I took particular note of from two days ago:

Year/Model Mileage MMR Amount Sale Amount
2017 Nissan Titan 21,000 miles $33,700 $31,000
2017 Hyundai Elantra 24,000 miles $11,200 $10,000
2019 Toyota Avalon 23,000 miles $30,400 $27,500
2019 Toyota Tacoma 27,000 miles $35,200 $34,750
2017 Toyota Tundra 33,000 miles $37,500 $35,000
2017 Rover Sport 27,000 miles $53,100 $51,750
2019 Audi Q5 4100 miles $41,200 $38,000
2018 BMW M3 20,000 miles $55,600 $51,000
2018 Mercedes GLS450 41,000 miles $43,300 $39,250
2016 Chevy Tahoe 66,000 miles $37,600 $35,000

Just a week ago, every Toyota Tacoma and Tundra that had a clean history report and average miles was bringing $5000 over MMR. As you can see from the numbers above, there was a major downward market shift.


Check out this 2017 Toyota Tundra with low mileage. The MMR on this one is $37,500, and a week ago it would have gaveled for over $40,000. The auctioneer starts at $35,000 and has no takers. They restart at $33,500 and ultimately sold it for $35,250.

Iíve also talked recently about the amazing money the new 2020 Corvettes were bringing at auction. A week ago, I saw one with an $88,000 window sticker price bring $109,500. It had an MMR of $108,000.

This week, there was an 1800-mile 2020 2LT very similar to the one I am reviewing this week. MMR on this one was $101,000. Auctioneer started it off at $80,000 but then she struggled to get to $95,000 and it finally sold at $97,500. That is $3,500 UNDER MMR on the hottest car on the market. That is what this week was like.


Although I saw the auction tanking this week, it will take a couple of weeks before that will affect the value of your trade-in vehicle. From auction prices to the real world lags before used values drop at the dealership level.

So, if you have a trade-in, and are contemplating getting a new vehicle, DO IT NOW. Timing is everything when trying to get the best possible overall deal.

Although auction prices were way down this week, it wonít affect you immediately, but I will tell you auction prices will fall again next weekÖ once the slide begins it takes weeks for the market to completely adjust back fully.

It is the end of the month, give all this some serious thought.
Related Articles
Special Thanksgiving Message From Jerry Reynolds
To educate yourself for the feeling of gratitude means to take nothing for granted, but to always seek out and value the kind that will stand behind the action. Nothing that is done for you is a matte... More ›
Thanksgiving Prayer For Our Military And First Responders
Thursday we will gather around the dinner table with family and friends to share good food, warm laughter, and the happy memories of Thanksgivings past. For many families whose loved ones serve in the... More ›
Edmunds: Used Car Values Dropping
I have told you on the Car Pro Show that I saw used car prices falling at the auction recently. Edmunds data agrees with this and odds are great the fall will continue through the rest of the year, a... More ›
Kevinís Famous Holiday Recipes
We always put these recipes in the newsletter around Thanksgiving and Christmas, so with turkey day just a few weeks away, it might be time to plan ahead.

Just a little history, back from the d... More ›
I'm looking to buy a used Chevrolet Tahoe. Is there a certain year newer than 2015 that is better than the other or years to avoid?
The Car Pro
Honestly no, the changes they made in 2015 were substantial and all years have been great. Not sure where you are but I have good dealers in every market for Chevy! Just click CERTIFIED DEALERS at my website.

Jerry Reynolds
Mike F
In anticipation of the drop in used car prices I sold my Honda Odessy leased vehicle for a crazy price. I am now in the market for a used vehicle. I have a second vehicle for transportation but I will be purchasing a 2015-2019 soon. When will we a drop in the used car market? I am prepared to wait until December but would like to act sooner.
The Car Pro
Best guess, October and even more in November, so hang on if you can, I think youíll be pleased.

Jerry Reynolds